| |
|
What is the Ideal Cure for Alcohol
Recovery?
The reason for this
article is to identify the clear-cut cure for the
treatment program for people who abuse or are dependent
on drugs and/or alcohol.
It is
well-known fact that no one treatment program or method
of rehab, in itself and by itself, can claim to be the
most effective in finding a cure or aid in the recovery
process. The only effective tool in a treatment
program, that can make a difference in the outcome and
length of sobriety, is the philosophy of treatment
should be based on a comprehensive plan which would
integrate, in the same treatment setting, all known
methods of recovery into one treatment setting. That
would mean the educational process, the 12 Step recovery
process as well as counseling by group or individual one
on one meetings, Life Style changes, attitudes and
motivation or combination of all of these coupled with a
Milieu or environment free of drug customs, old habits,
familiar surroundings that cause triggers and cravings
and pressures contributing to the addiction.
This dialogue is called
an ideal one. It means that, in reality, no one program
can integrate all elements of treatment for the simple
reason of time considerations, length of stay, financial
considerations, cost efficiency, availability of
well-trained counseling staff who are recovering
themselves and who are versed not only in addictive
behavior but have walked the walk and talked the talk
and finally discovered sobriety. There are many well
meaning Doctors, Psychologist and medical workers who
have no idea of what addiction consist of other than
from a text book and therefore have a hard time relating
to the problems of an addicted personality. Their
intentions are good but how would you like to have a
pilot land an airplane that only acquired the knowledge
from a book? Nothing can compare with experience.
Other factors such as physical facilities, for example a
sterile hospital setting, a converted residential house
or bed and breakfast Inn, can not possibly compete with
a specialty constructed facility for Alcohol and drug
treatment. Even the building codes are different for
special designed Alcohol and Drug Rehab Centers.
Facilities that are located within the same environment
that aggravated or contributed to the addiction are also
a problem. Many facilities locate with the closeness to
the beach where heavy drinking and drug use are
associated with triggers and cravings rather than
seeking out an isolated, remote location to introduce a
clean slate, a starting over state of mind that is so
necessary for the recovery of the addicted individual.
The ideal location for a Rehab center is on a secluded
desert Island a thousand miles from the nearest liquor
store or drug dealer. Not walking distance to the
nearest connection or looking out your window at beach
parties with an abundance of beer coolers and drug use.
The Alcohol-Drug Rehab Industry just doesn’t get it.
Up to 1935, Medical
Doctors pretty much had given up on Alcoholics and Drug
Users. When the Oxford group entered the scene and
subsidiary groups such as Alcoholic Anonymous discovered
a cure, then the medical industry took a look at “the
power of positive thinking” and spiritual influence on
the recovery process. It was not until the Insurance
Companies got involved in payment of claims for drug and
alcohol addiction did the medical community realize they
could make money doing this. It became all about the
money and it became terribly expensive with the average
30 day rehab program running between $20,000 to
$30,000. Then they discovered you couldn’t cure anyone
in a hospital. It took a classroom with skilled
Instructors and Mentors who have lived the problem and
found the solution. Some of the best examples of the
“old fashion cure” were the leaders in the Industry such
as Betty Ford, Hazelden and Sierra Tucson who had
followed for years and eventually left their 12 step
models and AA recovery to branch out into a more
lucrative field of prescribing medications and became
Medical Hospitals staffed with expensive Doctors,
physiologist and counselors with at least Master level
credentials. Gone were the old method of one drunk
reaching out a helping hand too another drunk and
showing him the way to sobriety and drug free life one
step at a time. A Wave spread across America for
licensing of Counselors, Treatment workers and
therapist. The States got involved in control,
licensing and regulations. Alcoholic Anonymous and most
Organized Religions fought against the licensure and
became basically exempt in most states. For after all,
Ministers and Drunks sobering up other drunks were
trained to do this much better than anyone could find in
a text book. Experience is the mother of all progress.
Ministers and AA answered to a higher power than the
governor of any given state and worked the steps that
were successful in millions of people coming to their
senses. Not through hospitals, not through feel good
clinics on the beach, but from tried and proven methods
of working the steps, one step at a time can any results
be obtained. Any rehab center that tells you that AA
does not work or that to substitute one drug for another
by using valium or antabuse or any other addictive
“cures” such as methadone, common sense should tell you
to run, don’t walk and get away from those good meaning
chaps who don’t have a clue as to what addiction is.
Addictive behavior creates other addictive behavior and
why throw gasoline into the fire to put it out? The
very first question in getting sober should be; Have you
had any experience in getting drunk and sobering up? How
long have you been sober?
However,
the purpose of this discussion is to give those
interested in recovery and living a drug free life as
well as all current and potential treatment programs a
guideline which would help them to develop a plan for
the most fitting option. It is for the families of
addicted persons, it is for the addictive users and
finally, it is for those interested in providing a cure
for alcohol or drug abuse.
In
theory, we can assume that, the closer any treatment
programs follows this method or this "ideal" philosophy,
the better the treatment outcome. Accordingly, it is
anticipated that any treatment program for alcohol and
drug clients will make every effort to launch its own
cure for addiction based on suggested treatment
methods. And by understanding this report, those
seeking help will have a better understanding of what
type and method of treatment is “ideal” and better for
the individual as opposed to being lost in some clinic
or hospital and being one face out of hundreds being
processed as in a cattle car. Hazelden is proud of the
fact that they process over Six hundred people each
month in rehab at their one facility in Minnesota. They
have four. Betty Ford takes great pride in the
thousands it has “processed” and turned out. Most
Medical facilities have jumped on the band wagon and
introduced a “medical’ model that makes rehab “painless”
and without complications. But those who have gone
before think that “detox” should not be painless or you
should remember the process from being so drunk and
drugged up and what you had to go through to sober up.
Experience tells us that we never learn from being right
all the time, we only learn from our mistakes. Detox is
not meant to be painless or forgotten easy. It is one of
those painful reminders that being drunk and out of
control is not a very pretty site. You also come to
realize that the person you were when drunk and high was
not a very nice person and you really did not like that
person very much. Depression, feelings of Guilt and
self esteem are changed greatly by just being sober and
clean. Why use artificial methods of feeling good when
you can have the real thing by just getting high on
life?
I.
Realistic Concepts OF DRUG AND ALCOHOL TREATMENT Methods
The most
recent studies and research on success of treatment of
clients abusing drugs and alcohol (Drug Abuse Treatment:
A national Study of Effectiveness by Robert L. Hubbard
et al; The University of North Carolina Press, 1989)
concluded very clearly that one of the most important
major factors which determines the outcome of treatment
is the length, the methods and intensity of treatment.
Taking in
consideration this factor, any philosophy of treatment
has to be founded on a all-inclusive model which makes
available to the prospective clients a multiple method
that lasts a considerable length and is intense in its
compliance. This means, among other things, that none of
the drug and alcohol treatment programs should adopt a
one-sided approach based on one preferred method (for
example, only group therapy; or only individual therapy;
or only attendance of AA, NA, CA and similar meetings).
Basically, we can distinguish five major general models
within which treatment of alcohol and drug clients can
take place. Each of these models incorporates a somewhat
different philosophical approach toward the makeup,
structure and the process of treatment.
These
models are as follows:
1. Residential
treatment model. This model can be subdivided into two
sub-models:
a. drug-free social
sub-model;
b.
Educational and/or behavioral modification
2. Day treatment model. This model
also can adhere either to drug-free sub-model or to the
medical sub-model.
3. Outpatient drug-free
model. By definition, this model never contains within
its frame any medical approach.
4. Medical outpatient
or In-patient model (for example, methadone clinics for
out patient, and Hospitals for In-Patient).
b. medical sub-model by prescribing anti-depressants and drugs
5. Self-help group
model (such as, for example, AA, NA, CA, ACA, etc.).
All the above-mentioned
models, in their varying degrees, serve a purpose and
can contribute to the successful outcome of treatment if
seen in proper point of view or if they function
fundamentally with other models and not as a separate or
isolated or an restricted occurrence. This simply means
that any single method by and of itself, is not the most
effective approach to sobriety or drug free state. They
must be joined with each other in order for the highest
and best results to obtain sobriety and drug Free
states. If medical complications exist, a short three
to five day intervention within a hospital perimeter may
be necessary if withdrawal symptoms are acute or medical
complications present themselves.
An Educational model
only dealing with lifestyle and behavior changes are
needed for a solid foundation but other models such as
group meetings and one on one counseling may also be an
essential part of recovery. An Intensive 90 day
Mentoring program following a 30 day Intensive
Residential treatment can double the odds of sobriety
and staying sober. Not seeking follow-up in a group or
intensive counseling sessions upon leaving either a
residential or medical treatment program intensifies and
magnifies the chances of failure from recovery. The
chances of success goes through the ceiling if upon
graduation from a residential treatment facility to
participation in an intensive ninety-day counseling and
mentoring program in a daily group session with one on
one interaction with a sponsor also known as a mentor or
counselor can put the rate of recovery at over 90%. The
chances of success doubles if not triples if combined
with additional models such as Self-help group and
mentoring programs.
We should
also seriously consider a sixth possible model. This
model is too often overlooked or neglected or considered
only slightly for the reasons that the type of clientele
it would fit is the most difficult, if not impossible,
to deal with. These are so-called "ping-pong" clients
that have a dual or a mixture of diagnosis; that is, who
suffer from both drug and alcohol addiction and switch
back and forth as economic or availability issues come
into play. One must realize that a drug is a drug is a
drug. By addressing the solution to sobriety, you
address also the method that leads to a drug free and
clean state of mind. Most if not all drug addicts seem
to substitute their continual drug use with an temporary
time out period and a switch of drug of choice to
alcohol abuse. Addiction is a indication; the cure is
in a behavior modification and a solid education
component that addresses the source of the behavior as
well as some of the causes that create the behavior in
the first place. This is accomplished by intensive
educational processes and group and individual
counseling. Working a program of sobriety leads to the
path of recovery.
This
leads us to a discussion of the steps we took to get
sobriety and drug free;
1. All drug and alcohol
treatment programs are to have a basic approach toward
treatment of their clients. This means that they are to
put together or make available to their clients a
variety of treatment methods consisting of the
individual therapy/counseling of assortment of
philosophies and influence; of group therapy/counseling
of mixture nature; family and couple therapy/counseling
by attendance and participation in Al-Anon or other self
help groups; and involvement in self-support groups
(such as AA, NA, CA, ACA, etc., meetings).
2. Treatment of drug
abusers and alcohol abusers can no longer be separated.
The studies and research across this nation clearly
indicate that, unless the clients are treated at the
same time and along with for both their drug and alcohol
problems, most resume heavy drinking or become heavy
drinkers after the so-called successful completion of
treatment without entering into a second phase of
intensive follow-up called a “mentoring Program”. With
this kind of outcome, it is difficult to talk about
successful completion of treatment without a second
phase of treatment usually lasting about Ninety days.
So any treatment program starts with the intensive 30
day rehab in-resident program but must be coupled with
and combined with a just as intensive 90 day follow-up
of concentrated mentoring (sponsor), one on one
counseling coupled with group sessions geared for
recovery.
3. The vast majority of
clients entering treatment now-a-days are a mix of drug
and alcohol users/abusers. The so-called "good old
days," when clients preferred one exact drug use or only
alcohol abuse, are possibly gone forever. Thus, any drug
and alcohol treatment program has to be changeable,
versatile, flexible, adaptable and adjustable to the
needs of their clients, who suffer from multiple
addictions, and to the constantly changing pattern of
drug and alcohol abuse as well as to the appearance of
new drugs on the market. Without a follow-up program
consisting of at least 90 days following the in-resident
treatment, the failure rate climbs through the ceiling
and chances of failure increases dramatically.
4. Each treatment
program, in the early stage of treatment, must consider
the need for detoxification of the client prior to the
beginning of treatment proper. Detoxification is not a
treatment per se. It is a beginning to any form of
treatment. The detoxification process can include the
medical approach, acupuncture, nutritional approach,
orthomolecular approach, naturopathic approach, social
detox approach or combination of some or all of the
above. Detox is simply a pre-treatment process and can
be accomplished prior or during the primary rehab
program.
5. Before any other
forms of treatment are recognized or applied, the major
force of any drug and alcohol treatment programs has to
be the immediate termination of drug and/or alcohol
use/abuse. No treatment can reasonably start while the
client continues to take drugs and/or drink alcohol.
This principle is valid for all type of clients
including dual/multiple diagnosis clients. Thus, a
period of time must be devoted to the issue of
successful accomplishment and maintenance of sobriety
and staying clean. Without achievement of this goal,
none of the other treatment approaches can work or be
effective. Any client, under the power of drugs and/or
alcohol, lacks the proper mental frame of mind favorable
to responding to the treatment intercession regardless
of the model that is being used or applied in this
respect. It also must be understood that a state of
intoxication or drug use can contribute and does
contribute to depression, guilt, remorse, feelings of
self inadequacy, loss of self esteem and countless other
feelings associated with and contributing to alcohol and
drug abuse. This tends to diminish as sobriety and being
clean is achieved.
6. Extensive
educational and preventive components of any treatment
process for drug and alcohol clients are a essential
factor in determining the outcome of any form of
treatment. Thus, each treatment program is to include
this principle in their approach and to undertake
education of their clients regarding various
comprehensive issues of the nature, effects and impact
of alcohol and other drugs on all characteristics of
human life (spiritual, mental, physical, social,
personal, marital, professional, vocational, etc.).
Anything short of an intensive 30 day educational and
behavioral modification program is sending someone into
battle without any ammunition. A solid groundwork of
triggers, cravings, and how to combat relapse is
critical to the success of any rehab program.
7. Alcohol and other
drug problems are considered to be a social and/or
family ailment. If this assumption is true, and most
national studies and research tend to support this
theory, then any treatment of these problems must engage
in the process of treatment not only family members but,
if possible and feasible, also close friends and, in
some instances, the employer also. Thus, all alcohol and
drug treatment programs are to include in their
treatment process family sessions, couples sessions and
sessions which include all significant others (friends,
girl-friends, co-workers, supervisors, etc.). Follow-up
and participation in an organized group such as Al-anon
is crucial in the recovery process.
8. The above mentioned
requirement indicates that one of the factors of any
treatment process is a initial evaluation or in-take,
evaluation of the client and establishment of an
individualized treatment plan. As the recent national
study on success of drug and alcohol abuse treatment
clearly indicates, one of the major reasons for failure
of treatment programs was that these programs lacked a
combination of both the intensive 30 day and a 90 day
follow-up of intensive, mentor-counseling in a group
such as AA and individual counseling with a Mentor
(sponsor) on a day to day basis. Thus, in order to
assure that all clients entering treatment are properly
motivated to stay in and respond positively to
treatment, all treatment programs are to pursue the
following important factors:
a. They are to enter
into a Intensive, In-Residential 30 day Educational and
behavior modification program;
b. Upon completion of
the initial 30 day intensive rehab, immediate follow up
and entering into a Ninety day, Mentor based, group
focus on sobriety and one on one counseling with a
mentor (sponsor) is mandatory for a successful
completion of rehab. Entering back into the community
with the help, guidance and direction of a mentor eases
the way back into sobriety and being drug free and clean
c. Upon completion of
the the first two phases of rehab (30 day In-residence
education and 90 day Mentor program) the final phase can
be entered into by participation in daily or weekly AA
meetings or support groups.
The National
Institute of health in their MATCH project sought to
determine the best treatment program for sobriety and
drug free state. The outcome was somewhat dismal as any
one single program by and of itself, failed miserably
with a 43 percent chance of success. However, when two
of the above methodologies were incorporated, the
success rate went up to 73 percent sobriety and being
clean at the end of one year. By combining three,
educational, behavior modification, followed by a ninety
day mentoring program with group counseling, in some
cases, the success rate exceeded 93% which is
statistically off the charts. The above-mentioned
national study in this respect shows that treatment
programs which developed such plans and which actively
involved intensive 30 day rehab followed by 90 day
mentor programs, had a much higher rate of success than
those who did not. It was clearly shown in this study
that their involvement and compliance with the
behavioral objectives for the progress and, most
importantly, motivates them to stay in treatment and
pursue their sobriety and remain clean.
9. The majority of drug and
alcohol clients either lack or, in the process of their
long history of alcohol and drug abuse, loose proper
social skills. This is an issue of interaction with
others and relatedness to others. Many clients are
angry, hostile, violent, guilt-ridden, embarrassed,
paranoid, unable to form warm and lasting relationships;
self-defeating, self-destructive, are in denial,
undermine themselves, avoiding social interaction, etc.
In order that any alcohol and drug treatment program
succeeds in treating their drug and alcohol clients,
they are to include into the very fabric of treatment
training programs that would help them in this respect.
10. As a result of a
long history of drug and/or alcohol abuse, many clients
either had never acquired any vocational or occupational
skills or their lost them. Thus, the issues of
vocational and/or occupational habilitation and
rehabilitation of these clients are crucial for the
successful outcome of any treatment program in this
respect. For this reason, each treatment program is to
incorporate into their treatment process a
vocational/occupational counseling and/or to establish
an effective and reliable source/resource of such
counseling and training to which any client in need can
be referred without delays and complications.
11. One of the most
important factors in deterring relapse and for
establishment of a relapse prevention network is the
development and provision of well-planned and
thought-through follow-up and after-care services. Each
drug and alcohol program is to establish these services
in a consistent manner and on the regular basis. Before
discharge of any client, and during the treatment
process, the counselor is to discuss with and to explain
to his/her clients the importance and the need for
follow-up and after-care as a deterrent to relapse, in
order to solicit a commitment from the client to return
back to the program or to be contacted at his/her home
(by mail, telephone, etc.) on a regular basis for a
certain period of time. A minimum of ninety days
intensive Mentor (sponsor) Counseling in both individual
and group sessions is mandatory for successful
completion of the program.
12. One of the many
factors influencing a positive outcome of treatment of
drug and alcohol clients is a pleasant, comfortable,
warm, relaxed and peaceful environment (physical and
mental) in which treatment takes place. Thus,
establishment of such an environment within each
treatment program is a must. Treatment environment has
to have a calming and stabilizing effect on the client.
One of the many problems these clients experience is
instability, turmoil, uncertainty, misery, discomfort
and restlessness. An environment that does not offer
comfort, peace, stability, relaxed and pleasant
atmosphere cannot be effective in its treatment effort.
The opposite is true: it will further potentiate these
problems within the client. This is the reason why the
design of treatment environment should be given an equal
consideration with all other factors of the successful
outcome of treatment. Locating near the beach is not
helpful to recovery, but a constant reminder of boozing,
partying, drugging and using is not conducive to a solid
rehab program. Breaking old habits, getting away from
old environments and watering holes are a key ingredient
in recovery. Do not fall for the close to the action
syndrome. Get away far from the maddening crowd and
rebuild your life one day at a time. A rehab center is
not best suited in your back yard. It should be away
from old habits, familiar surroundings, even friends,
family and a job can contribute to stress. Consider an
out of state rehab center for the simple fact that life
altering changes are a must. A clean slate. A new start
is critical in the rehab process.
13. Connected with the
above requirement of a comfortable treatment environment
is the need for recreational activities, nutritional and
dietary counseling and mental and physical exercises.
Each treatment program is to incorporate into their
treatment process this consideration, providing
varieties of approaches for these types of activities
either within their programs (for residential
facilities) or by a reliable and efficient referral,
establishing a positive working relationship with the
agencies that specialize in these particular activities
(for outpatient drug-free programs). A gym is a must as
well as staying away from junk foods that destroy the
come back process.
An integral component
of any treatment program, as far as mental exercises are
concerned, is to offer its clients training in various
relaxation technique, guided imagery, self-hypnosis,
biofeedback, meditation, autogenic training and similar
techniques. These techniques proved themselves to be
valuable, effective and efficient tools in comprehensive
treatment programs for drug and alcohol clients.
14. As mentioned
previously, one of the most important factors of the
successful outcome of treatment is to motivate all
alcohol and drug clients to stay in treatment for a long
period of time. The length of treatment seems to be a
decisive factor in this respect. It can be substituted
only by intensity of treatment. The national study
clearly indicates that treatment below three months
period (Consisting of 30 day In-residential treatment
followed by a 90 day intensive Mentoring-individual and
group counseling) is ineffective. The optimal length of
stay in treatment with less intensive models was found
to be minimum six months to one year. Thus, all drug and
alcohol treatment programs are to develop and to
implement various methods by which all clients could be
properly motivated to remain in treatment for a long
period enough in order to receive maximum benefit from
the offered treatment. The single most effective
treatment is 30 day in-residence educational and
behavioral modification followed up by a 90 day
intensive, one on one individual counseling-mentoring
program with 90 group meetings for ninety days. This
program is in two phases, the first being in a quiet
away from it all environment followed by phase two of
returning to the community, resuming work or looking for
work integrating 90 meetings and daily mentor-counseling
(sponsorship)
Use of self-help
groups. The substance abuse field provides one of the
most well known and effective self-help models in
existence, Alcoholics Anonymous (A.A.) and its
Twelve-Step Program. Members are not "recovered" but
"recovering" - exemplifying the philosophy that
addiction/recovery is a lifelong process and not a
static state.
Since the
multiply diagnosed are substance abusers, A.A., N.A.,
C.A., A.C.A., etc. are all groups that can be
instrumental in maintaining abstinence. However, for
this population, caregivers must once again be aware of
their special needs. Self-help meetings however, can be
set up at the facility known to the clients. Such
"sheltered" meetings act as transitional opportunities
to train clients in appropriate social skills. Treatment
personnel can act as buffers and help the addicted
individual to feel that they are full members of these
meetings by attending meetings with them and by serving
as a role model during social interactions, caregivers
can help to initiate conversations and diffuse possible
problems.
III.
ISSUES OF STAFFING.
Basically, three issues need to be considered in this
respect:
a. The
qualification requirements for the staff members; and
b.
Optimal caseload for each individual counselor.
c. Being
a recovered alcoholic and sobriety for at least five
years.
In
general, each member of the treatment staff is required
to have the following qualifications:
1.
Thorough knowledge and understanding of drug and alcohol
problems and the treatment processes.
2.
Knowledge and understanding of biochemical,
physiological, family, social and psychological effects
of drugs and alcohol.
3.
Knowledge of community services and understanding of
referral procedures, follow-up and after care.
4.
Ability to develop, plan and organize treatment services
and related activities.
5.
Knowledge and ability to conduct individual counseling,
and trends and to lead and actively participate in group
meetings or discussions of the variety of approaches and
philosophies.
6.
Thorough knowledge of and well-developed skills in
conducting structural interviews and one on one
counseling.
7.
Ability and skills to properly document, with clarity
and meaningfulness, all treatment activities in general.
8.
Knowledge of all Federal, State and Local laws, policies
and procedures, regulating drug and alcohol programs and
of the issues of confidentiality.
9.
Willingness to participate in continuous education
workshops and various professional trainings for the
purpose of implementation of the new and innovative
treatment techniques, thus, avoiding stagnation,
regression and burn-out.
10. Should be
a member in good standing of National Associations for
Addiction Professionals. (Mr. Alexander, Director of
Education is a member of good standing of the National
Association of Alcohol and Drug Addiction Counselors;
NAADAC #91169)
The issue of how big a
caseload each counselor should have for the effective
outcome of treatment is a crucial one. In general, the
smaller the caseload, the more time for treatment of
each individual case is available to the counselor and
to each prospective client; and vice versa: too big a
caseload undermines positive effect and successful
outcome of treatment. For this reason the ideal number
of clients that each counselor is to carry, should not
exceed 10 to 12 clients per week. The number should
never exceed more than 15 clients per counselor. Above
this number the quality of the offered treatment is
highly questionable.
Each treatment program
is to develop the line of clinical and administrative
supervision, responsibility and accountability for each
member of the treatment staff.
IV.
SPECIFIC PROGRAMS
1.
Residential or In-patient Programs.
Each
residential facility is recommended to offer to their
drug and alcohol clients the following components:
a.
combined treatment of drug and alcohol clients with
paying proper attention to the specificity of the needs
of each client and the primary drug of abuse, without
overlooking or underestimating the secondary drugs of
abuse and/or alcohol.
b.
Detoxification by the means of Social Detox,
acupuncture, or medical detox, combined with the
nutritional, dietary and orthomolecular approach and
biofeedback, hypnosis and other relaxation techniques.
c. Daily
individual therapy/counseling, incorporating various
modalities as suited to the individualized and unique
needs of each client
d. Daily
group therapy/counseling of various modalities and
trends.
e. Daily
educational study sessions consisting of at least Six
hours per day.
f. Daily
participation in A.A., N.A., C.A., A.C.A. and similar
self-help meetings as needed and as indicated by the
treatment plan.
g. Daily
meditation, self-hypnosis, relaxation, guided imagery,
Tai Chi or prayer, autogenic training and similar
productive activities.
h. Daily
recreational activities and physical exercises.
i.
Availability of vocational and occupational counseling.
j.
Continuous educational sessions which address the issues
of drugs, alcohol and new drugs and their disastrous and
adverse effects on spiritual, mental, physical,
vocational, professional, marital, social, parental and
economic life.
k.
Training in assertiveness, social skills, proper
positive self-image, self-confidence and parental
skills.
l.
Facility management meetings - housekeeping.
The
intensity of treatment is crucial if the length of the
residential treatment is to be shortened, making it
cost-effective. The ideal time spent in treatment is
between one month to three months. However, this is not
always feasible for many practical and economic reasons.
The effective alternative is one month followed by an
intensive, ninety day mentor program and release back
into the community to gradually re-start their life.
If the above-described structure and intensity of
treatment is followed with a ninety day, ninety meeting
plan, It can effectively substitute for the longer
period of treatment, provided that the residential
program has a well-planned follow-up and aftercare
services with contact with the mentor or sponsor.
According
to the national study and research, mentioned at the
beginning of this paper, each of the mentioned treatment
programs are equally effective in the treatment of
substance abuse client.
Because
of these findings, the ideal situation would be in
having treatment facilities that would provide or make
available all these modalities in a combined manner.
5. Issues
of Social versus Medical Model of Treatment.
The
medical model of treatment is applicable primarily and
mainly during the detoxification period. Besides these
two approaches, the medical model uses, as a treatment
method for addiction, continuous administration of
Disulfiram (Antabuse) and opiate antagonists -
Naltrexone (Trexan).
For
detoxification from opiates primarily Methadone and
Darvon (Propoxyphene) are used.
As Marc
A. Schuckit, M.D. pointed out ("Drug and Alcohol Abuse:
A Clinical Guide to Diagnosis and Treatment;" Plenum
Medical Book Company, 1989), Methadone, as well as
Darvon, does not "cure" opiate addiction. Methadone
maintenance is used to help the addict to develop a
life-style free of street drugs in order to improve
functioning within the family and job, to decrease
problems with the law, and to improve health.
As
pointed out above, the success of Methadone maintenance
largely depends on to what extent Methadone clinics
incorporate into their programs a holistic approach:
outreach to families, legal advice, job counseling,
referral to N.A., and, specifically, according to
Schuckit, to cognitive and supportive psychotherapies
and to long-term social model treatment.
Thus, the
medical model, in itself and by itself, without
incorporation of a holistic approach, does not yield
lasting results of the offered treatment. It has been
proven time and again, in over Seventy years of
experience and some Two Million active participants in
AA, that the Medical Model does not work. It is a
temporary fix and not a long term solution. Intensive
30 day Residential treatment, combined with a ninety day
Mentoring-Group attendance model seems to be the most
effective treatment.
The same
is true about treatment of alcoholics with Disulfiram (Antabuse):
in itself and by itself, this type of treatment tends to
have very short-lived results. Unless the alcoholic is
involved in a long-term psychotherapy, behavior
modification and in A.A. programs, the usefulness of
Disulfiram therapy does not exceed a placebo effect.
In the
process of detoxification from drugs and alcohol,
administration of vitamins and minerals is important
because of the long-term depletion of these components
from the body by the client's neglect to supply them to
the body through proper food in take.
In
general, alcoholic and drug addict rehabilitation
consists of a series of general helping maneuvers aimed
at increasing and maintaining the highest level of
motivation toward abstinence and recovery, helping the
individual to reestablish a life-style without alcohol
and drugs, and maintaining healthy physical and mental
functioning.
According
to Schuckit, therapy involves a commonsense approach to
group and individual counseling, long-term follow-up,
working with the client and avoiding most medications.
On the
down-side, substituting one drug for another and the
chances of re-addiction or cross addiction sometimes
does not justify or warrant the risk. Extreme caution
should be used with using the medical model for
rehabilitation. To become addicted to another drug is
self defeating and may cause relapse or at the very
least, needing additional rehabilitation to address
another addiction caused by the medicating for the first
addiction. It is a vicious spiral and should be avoided
at all cost.
ISSUES
OF FUNDING AND COST EFFECTIVENESS.
It is a
well-known fact that the majority of drug and alcohol
clients, and most of the dual/multiple diagnosis
clients, are unable to finance or pay for their
treatment or they are able to do so only in a limited
manner not sufficient enough for the cost-recovery of
the drug and alcohol treatment programs. Thus, they
depend on private pay and loans from family and friends.
The same
study also shows clearly that substantial benefits to
the nation occur from public investment in drug and
alcohol abuse treatment. Relative to the cost of
treatment, great benefits result from all treatment
models and especially from their combined approach, as
outlined in this paper.
The
overwhelming evidence shows that public expenditures for
substance abuse treatment are wise and prudent
investments, despite the fact that substance abuse is a
chronic condition which typically requires multiple
treatment episodes for individuals affected. An analysis
of the California drug abuse services network by Dr.
Victor Tabbush of UCLA estimates that for every dollar
spent for drug and alcohol treatment, $11.54 of social
costs is saved. These figures speak for themselves.
Alcohol
and drug treatment is expensive. It cost between $20,000
to $30,000 for the medical model and most in-patient,
residential treatment programs. The Manor house charges
$10,000 or almost half price of a medical hospital model
but delivers a 120 day program that consist of 30 days
in-resident, in-house treatment for phase one followed
by a ninety day intensive Mentor program in your own
home city. Alcohol and drug rehab is expensive. But can
you afford the cost not too? The cost of human lives
can not be measured in dollars and sense. The cost of
human suffering and pain can not be measured by out of
pocket expenses. You will find in a very short time, it
cost more to continue drinking and drugging than it cost
to stop.
Give us a
call at 1-800-396-5534 and find the cure you have been
praying for.
|